Regenerative Agriculture: Three Expert Perspectives
At the Collective's May event, three panelists discussed how regenerative agriculture can drive value for farmers, businesses, and communities.
Our soil is in a critical state. Conventional agricultural practices are decimating the lifegiving properties of soil around the globe, releasing additional carbon into the atmosphere and rendering croplands infertile. Already a third of our planet’s soil is degraded, and UNESCO predicts that the number could be as high as 90% by 2050. Nowhere is immune — agricultural systems from giant operations in the Midwest to subsistence farms in rural Malawi are affected by soil degradation.
Regenerative agriculture offers a way forward, using sustainable land management practices to not only avoid doing more harm, but also to restore already degraded soil. At our fourth community networking event, we welcomed three expert panelists to share their perspectives on this pressing agricultural issue:Melissa Spear, Executive Director at Tilth Alliance; Paul Shoemaker, CEO of Carnation Farms; and Richard Moe, Principal Technical Program Manager at Opportunity International’s Digital Innovation Group.
The Global Impact Collective brought together a diverse group of professionals from farmers to agronomists to professors to discuss this important subject. The topics ranged from the adoption to the economics and future of regenerative agriculture. A few key themes emerged:
Challenges
Establishing Standards of Regenerative Agriculture
Regenerative agriculture is widely defined as farming practices that are minimally disruptive to the soil, exercise crop diversity, utilize cover crops in the off season, and maintain living roots. However, unlike the rigorous criteria built around organic certification, we don’t yet have universally accepted standards and certifications for what it means to claim a company practices regenerative agriculture. If businesses and governments wish to certify and systematize regenerative farming, and if they want consumers to trust the certification, they will need hardier definitions.
Greenwashing: “Because it doesn’t have a definition, because there is no legal standard, regenerative agriculture is subject to greenwashing,” Melissa said. She pointed out that many large corporate food companies implement a no-till policy and label themselves regenerative despite still using pesticides and herbicides. “We have to figure out how to clarify and protect the integrity of what it is that we’re calling regenerative.”
“Organic Plus”: Despite the term generally gaining traction, an average consumer will not have a clear idea of what regenerative agriculture means when the label appears on a food item. Paul suggested pitching the concept to consumers as “organic plus,” signifying that regenerative food has all the same qualifications of organic food plus the benefit of reinvigorating the soil.
Entrenched Political Systems
A long history of political incentives has led the United States to favor large, corporate, conventional farms, often at the expense of smaller ones. Changing this existing bureaucracy is slow and arduous, but it can be done. Europe, for instance, is 10-15% organic, compared to only 1-2% in the US.
Historical precedent: Paul identified three moments in American farming that led to our current agricultural system:
At the end of World War II, pesticides and herbicides were commercialized on a broad scale.
Earl Butz, the Secretary of Agriculture under Richard Nixon and Gerald Ford, promoted a “get big or get out” approach to farming and urged farmers to plant commodity monocrops like corn “from fencerow to fencerow.”
The focus on ethanol created a strong orientation towards conventional agriculture.
Lack of subsidies and financial support: The 2018 Farm Bill allocated $428 billion dollars over five years for agricultural subsidies with the majority of those funds supporting conventional farming. The federal financial support for sustainable farming is extremely low by comparison, and the shift from conventional to regenerative is difficult.
Economic Barriers to Adoption
“It’s expensive to be an organic, regenerative farmer,” Melissa said. “You have higher labor costs, you make different kinds of investments, it’s a more complicated method of farming, and certification costs money.”
Slow transition time: The transition period from conventional to organic certified is three years, and during that time the farmer cannot sell the food with an organic premium despite farming organically.
Lack of information: Rich pointed out that small-scale farmers, especially those living rurally and experiencing extreme poverty, often don’t know how to find markets, negotiate for better prices, and understand the economic outputs of their own farms. Existing resources are hard to access without basic literacy and access to the internet. “Getting information to the end user is critical,” he said.
Promising Developments
Farmers Educating Farmers
It’s critical that farmers teach one another. “We know that farmers learn best from farmers,” said Rich. To leverage this insight, Opportunity International is setting up a mentorship program in rural African farming communities and building its educational tools around insights gathered from the local farmers themselves. Rich mentioned OI’s agricultural team in Rwanda has implemented a system of “farmer support agents.” He says, “They get a bicycle, a pair of boots, a smartphone, and training, and in exchange they take the learnings out into their communities and spread it amongst the farmers in that community.”
Melissa also pointed to the Transition to Organic Partnership Program, which helps provide resources to aspiring organic and regenerative farmers. “Paying farmers to talk to farmers: that is really where the information gets transferred, because it’s often not as simple as reading a couple sentences. You need someone there to show you, to explain it to you, to demonstrate.”
Technological Advancements
Recent developments in technology, especially in the AI sector, have exciting implications for agriculture and education.
Precision agriculture: With better instruments, companies and farmers can manage their farms more effectively. Robotic tools that monitor the soil, for instance, can inform users when they need to irrigate, look for pests, know when to apply pesticides, and so forth. “I think this is actually going to reduce the use of some of the more toxic synthetic chemicals on even conventional farms,” Melissa said. “Any stop toward eliminating or reducing the use of those chemicals is good.”
Agricultural education: Using generative AI and other tools, Rich and the Digital Innovation Group at Opportunity International are building a WhatsApp chatbot to help rural farmers in the field get answers to their questions. Given many might be illiterate, the bot can take verbal inputs in the farmers’ native languages, and it can analyze pictures of crops to determine diseases and offer advice.
Climate and Economic Resilience
Farms that practice regenerative agriculture withstand both market pressures and extreme weather. "You're more resilient to drought. You’re more resilient to heat. Your yields will remain higher in the face of a drastic climatic event,” Melissa said.
Community relevance: Paul extrapolated this concept into economic resilience for whole communities by extension, using White Oak Pastures as an example. “They employ nearly a couple hundred people in their local community,” he said. “That’s economic resilience at all levels. The way to try to think about economic resilience is to think locally, think regionally, think within the Puget Sound to try to solve the problem in that domain if you have the chance.”
Interested customers: If consumers remain willing to pay the price premium for organic food, regenerative products will likely also do well on the market provided the certification issues are solved.
Shifting markets: Melissa mentioned market research by the Organic Trade Association that found young people driving demand for organic food. “Younger generations are faced with this existential crisis of climate change, are recognizing that eating is a political act, and that their food choices actually have social, environmental, and economic impacts. And they are willing to make the investment to go organic and regenerative.”
Attendees mingle before the panel.
Reflections
As the panel ended, the discussion was far from over with an insightful Q&A and further networking discussion. Dan Schiaffo, a consultant at Slalom who is currently pursuing a master’s program focused on sustainability, was left thinking about how to shift the public’s focus from organic to regenerative. “This sort of conversation is music to my ears. I absolutely love it,” he said.
Pamela Cardone shared the recent documentary Common Ground as a resource. The question of how to inspire conventional farms to use regenerative methods —even those who are hostile towards sustainability — piqued her interest as a financial risk analyst. “We have to show that they will make more money, even without the principles.” She wants to put her risk knowledge to better use in this space.
Several attendees were intimately familiar with the challenges growers face as growers themselves. George Thomas owns an alfalfa farm and recently got a grant from Tilth Alliance to plant a food forest and a prairie strip. The difficulty of growing alfalfa means that getting organic certified is a very unlikely prospect, but he still wants to make the farm more regenerative. “It’s important work. I think I could get there, eventually.”
Andrew Tuttle, a permaculture expert and educator currently restoring a historic farm in Arlington, is creating an online learning platform where participants can partake in virtual tours of regenerative lands. He wanted to stress that there is big investment in the field from nongovernmental sources. “The thing is, regenerative farming can make people really, really rich,” he said. “We don’t talk about that enough, and if it were more widely known, we could convince more farms to make the switch.”
He was excited to attend the event and wished there were more like it in his field. “We just need a pure opportunity to get together because the future of this industry depends on community. Cultural relationship-building comes from working together, and this is the way you do that.”
Zachary Gray from Adaptive Symbiotic Technologies, a company that is using fungi to protect plants from heat stress and difficult environments, echoed that sentiment.
The diversity of backgrounds and professions present at the event highlight just how interdisciplinary the challenge of implementing regenerative agriculture is, and the networking that took place promises that this wicked challenge has ever more brilliant minds working on it. A huge thank you to our panelists and everyone who attended.
Follow us on LinkedIn to stay connected to this vibrant and growing community, and we hope to see you at our next event in the fall.
Resources
Coalition for Organic and Regenerative Agriculture (CORA)is a coalition of farmers, businesses, organizations, and activists advocating for progressive programs and policies in support of organic and regenerative agriculture in Washington State. The Tilth Alliance is one of the 11 member organizations.
White Oak Pastures transitioned away from industrial agriculture techniques in 1995 and began operating their farm as a living ecosystem. They now raise 10 species of humanely treated animals, and the land is managed to increase living organic matter. They employ more than 155 members of their local community.
Common Ground Filmis the sequel to Kiss the Ground, which the filmmakers claim inspired the United States Department of Agriculture (USDA) to put $20 billion toward soil health. The film explores the money, power, and politics intertwined in our broken food system and profiles farmers using regenerative agriculture models that could stabilize the climate, improve health, and grow America’s economy.
Transition to Organic Partnership Program is investing up to $100 million over five years in cooperative agreements with non-profit organizations providing technical assistance support, training, education, and outreach to aspiring organic farmers.
The Nature Conservancysupports building regenerative food systems and has a variety of resources on regenerative practices, food system solutions, technological innovations, as well as their Foodscapes Report, which provides a global perspective on necessary food systems transitions to meet “this century’s most pressing challenge: the threats posed by climate change, biodiversity loss, and increased demand on the integrity of the global food system.”
Regenerative Agriculture Podcastis a podcast for professional growers and agronomists who want to learn about the science and principles of regenerative agriculture systems to increase quality, yield, and profitability.
Noble Research Institutewas founded in 1945 and is the nation’s largest nonprofit dedicated to farm and ranch management education to build soil health and increase profitability on U.S. farms and ranches. The organization has an entire category of research dedicated to regenerative agriculture.
Regenerative Agriculture: Healing Soils to Heal the World
Women's History Month 2025: Five Women Who Shaped Our Food Systems
Food Waste Prevention in the Pacific Northwest: Three Expert Perspectives
We want to work with you!
James Bernard
Jan 8, 2024
3 min read
We’re excited to have just launched the Global Impact Collective, a consultancy focused on helping your organization use design thinking to shape a world where people have access to safe, reliable food sources that reduce waste; where high-quality healthcare is available to all; and where climate change can be addressed through innovation.
Our Team has decades of collective experience working with some of the most impactful organizations in the world. We’ve seen firsthand the power of design thinking as a way to drive innovation – now we want to help you apply this to impact and sustainability programs at your organization.
We will work with a variety of organizations of any size and scale. Read on to see how.
Are you attending GreenBiz 24 in Phoenix in February? We’re conducting a circularity workshop on the first day of the conference. We’d love to connect with you in person any time that week!
Companies with a mission-driven ethos
Companies can prosper and do good in the world. In fact, that’s exactly what employees, shareholders, and consumers expect. Over the last decade, worked with dozens of companies that have a mission-driven ethos, including Unilever, Cargill, PepsiCo, and others.
An example of how this plays out: At Microsoft, I headed up Partners in Learning, a global program that worked with teachers and school leaders to use effectively in classrooms. We trained millions of teachers, school leaders, and policymakers.
Founding Advisor Don Coyner also worked in Microsoft Education, helping design relevant products for teachers, including Teams for Education, OneNote, Immersive Reader and the Reading Coach. Don recalls how important it was to visit a variety of schools to see the challenges that teachers face when using new technologies in diverse classrooms.
If you work for a company – whatever size -with a mission-driven ethos, we can help you infuse human-centered design into future product, program, and partnership development. Our expertise in product development, industrial design, user experience, conservation, partnerships, branding, and storytelling means we will bring a multi-dimensional approach your work, ensuring that future solutions are designed, first and foremost, with the human experience in mind.
Foundations and family offices
New forms of private philanthropy and investment have recently taken shape, including impact investments, taking equity in small businesses, and other investment vehicles. If you work at a foundation or family office, we can help you use design thinking to ensure that you are deploying resources to the most impactful initiatives around the world.
Co-founder Carey Renn worked for 16 years at Vulcan, Paul Allen’s investment, innovation and philanthropic organization. She and her team led many of the major social impact and conservation efforts across multiple sectors of interest to Paul. Carey led the development of the Allen Brain Atlas, was instrumental in the launch of the Allen Institute for Brain Science, led the launch of the Allen Institute for Artificial Intelligence, the Great Elephant Census, Earth Ranger, Sky Light, and several other initiatives at the intersection of conservation and technology.
Carey epitomizes what sets the Collective apart: her formal training in neuroscience, which evolved into technology and human centered design, allowing her to carve out a unique niche at the convergence of science, data, technology, and discovery. This extensive experience positions her take on the challenges the Collective looks to address.
NGOs and non-profit organizations
Nonprofits often have the best perspective on what people need in a community – they are the eyes and ears with true local perspective. Founding Advisor Surya Vanka has worked with numerous non-profits to deploy design solutions, including an organization focused on girls' education in Sierra Leone and a group working on homelessness in Seattle.
Our partner, Judith Hochhauser Schneider, led corporate partnerships for the World Wildlife Fund, working with the likes of Walmart, Coca-Cola, and Starbucks on environmental sustainability programs. Each of these companies, and their corporate foundations, are making significant investments in improving supply chain transparency, increasing circularity, and driving conservation efforts.
If you work for an NGO or non-profit organization, we can help you design efficient, appropriate solutions to enhance new programs, partnerships, and products, helping improve lives and raise more money.
Government and multilateral institutions
Government agencies are investing in new technologies, both domestically and internationally, leading to more efficient delivery of government service and improvement of lives in emerging economies. With the growth of better connectivity and access around the world, we believe there’s unlimited potential to apply human-centered design principles with government organizations.
I once worked on a donor-funded tech platform called OpenLMIS that helped governments in developing countries ensure delivery of medicines to remote clinics. The success of the partnership was dependent on understanding the needs of health workers, ministry officials, patients, and others in the supply chain, many of whom had limited connectivity, literacy, and access to electricity.
If you work for a government institution, we’d love to help you consider the best options for designing new tools, platforms, apps, programs, and approaches to your audience.
We’d love to hear from you -- drop us a line! You can find more specific information about how we work with clients on the Our Process page.
